Evaluating Creative Scholarship - Anthony Collins

This book challenges the dominance of third-person objectivity and measurement-based evaluation in academia. The first section explores the epistemological significance of vulnerability, showing how relational knowledge and deep listening contrast with the detached stance of conventional research. The second section critiques current systems of academic evaluation that prioritize outcome over process and objectivity over insight. Here, the book draws on systems theory, Bloom’s taxonomy, and media literacy to advocate for a more holistic and responsive framework—one that honors how creative work unfolds in stages, across time, and through dialogue. The third section turns to pedagogy, offering a vision of teaching and learning grounded in presence rather than performance. It explores how storytelling, reflection, and open-ended inquiry foster transformation in both students and faculty. This section also considers how to assess growth in creative fields—challenging traditional metrics in favor of context-sensitive evaluation that recognizes emotional and intellectual labor. Finally, the book addresses institutional reform. It presents practical tools, templates, and policy suggestions for building more humane and inclusive evaluation practices. Ultimately, the book is a deeply reflective and practical guide for anyone working at the intersection of creativity and academia. It offers not just a critique of how we evaluate, but a vision for what academic life can become when we value the full complexity of being human.